Turkish Policy Makers for DO MORE | Turk Pak Relations Good but Not Enough | More Trade & Defense Cooperation Needed | Seek Expansion of Makkah Pact including Egypt as Member

    0
    166

    STRATCOM Public Forum and Roundtable “Reshaping Regional Security Architecture: Strategic Partnership and Multilateral Cooperation from a Türkiye-Pakistan Perspective”

    Tazeen Akhtar

    Türkiye is keen to enhance trade as well as defence cooperation with Pakistan. Türkiye looks forward to more countries joining the Makkah Agreement to face the emerging threats and challenges of hybrid and ultra-hybrid wars in the future, despite the fact that a nuclear power and an economic giant are already there.

    Türkiye promotes the narrative of expansion of the Makkah Pact in the name of Regional Ownership of Regional Solutions to Regional Disputes.Turkish policy makers say that bilateral relations are good but not enough and both sides need to speed up trade.

    Here it is worth mentioning that Pak-Turk leaders have set a target to take the trade level up to $5 Billion. The participant Turkish policy makers said  relations are good but not enough. The trade should be increased according to the relations.Bilateral trade is in Türkiye’s favour – clearly, and consistently for the last 10+ years. Pakistan has never had a surplus with Türkiye in recent history.

    The Turkish policy makers opine that Pak-Turk defence cooperation is fine but not enough and a bigger alliance is required to meet the threats. Turkish side sees Egypt as the next member of the Makkah Agreement. They stressed regional platform including Egypt for defence and economy.

    They expressed these views at Centre for Afghanistan, Middle East and Africa (CAMEA) at the Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad (ISSI), that  jointly with the Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye Directorate of Communications and the Embassy of the Republic of Türkiye in Islamabad, organised a STRATCOM Public Forum titled “Reshaping Regional Security Architecture: Strategic Partnership and Multilateral Cooperation from a Türkiye-Pakistan Perspective.”

    Ambassador Khalid Mahmood, Chairman BOG, ISSI, highlighted the deep-rooted historical, cultural and strategic bonds between Pakistan and Türkiye, reaffirming their commitment to strengthening cooperation in defence, security, trade, technology and regional connectivity, as well as promoting regional peace, stability and a balanced international order.

    Ambassador Irfan Neziroglu, Ambassador of Türkiye, wars are complex now. Turkiye and Pakistan are not partners but brothers. Our relations are eternal. He emphasised the unique people-to-people bonds underpinning bilateral relations. He stressed the need to counter disinformation, strengthen information resilience and explore opportunities arising from growing trade ties and Turkish investment in Pakistan.

    Ambassador said , biltareal trade is increasing and for defense both sides trust each other that is the base of cooperation in defense. He said Makkah agreement is new chapter in the trilateral cooperation.

    He said the three countries (Saudia Turkiye Pakistan) have a history of good relations and common vision on future. The resources of three nations combined are for the stability , peace and prosperity of their people and the region. He said Turkiye supports Pakistani stance on Kashmir and calls for the just solution of this dispute according to aspirations of the indegenous people.

    (Saudia Turkiye relations before Makkah Agreement were never satsifactory if we see the history of bilateral relations – Recommending a more bigger defense alliance with Egypt especially mentioned leads to the hypothesis that Turkiye wants two things at one time – be in the Makkah Agreement but keep from contributing in the defense of Saudia from Houthis)

    Professor Dr. Burhanettin Duran, Head of Communications, Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye, highlighted the growing importance of strategic communication amid geopolitical and technological transformations. He underscored the challenges posed by disinformation and digital manipulation, emphasising international cooperation, information integrity and public trust, while highlighting the STRATCOM Summit’s role in fostering dialogue and societal resilience.

    A panel discussion followed, moderated by Dr. Hayati ÜNLÜ, Faculty Member, Turkish National Defence University.

    ” Three Brothers – 2021″ Military Exercise is Manifestation of Strong Brotherly Bond between Azerbaijan, Pakistan, Turkey; Khazar Farhadov

    Federal Minister for Information and Broadcasting, Attaullah Tarar, highlighted the longstanding Pakistan–Türkiye partnership and called for institutionalised cooperation in strategic communications to counter disinformation and digital threats. He proposed a bilateral strategic communications agreement and a joint working group comprising government institutions, academia and think tanks.

    Tarar shared that Pakistan has already moved forward on the digital side, setting up the very first state-of-the-art Digital Center in March 2025. He said there is not only the Genocide in Gaza but it is ECOCIDE as well.Minister Tarar stressed institutional cooperation for defence and Fikri supported his point.

    On fake news / disinformation check, Tarar proposed to form Joint Social Media Accounts Platform. He said we need to fight back this challenge together and for that collaboration is required. He said we have a secretariat equipped for that purpose. Tarar shared the example of D-8 and said the organization has its own Media Wing that is opening a media secretariat. We have tools. We can have Joint Fact Check, we can Frame the Narratives.

    Fikri Işık, Former Minister of National Defence of Türkiye, emphasised accelerating bilateral cooperation against hybrid threats, cyberattacks and technological competition. He called for moving beyond traditional defence cooperation towards joint research, development and production, alongside stronger institutional mechanisms and inclusive regional security partnerships.

    Fikri said, yes! there are some issues in Turk-Pak cooperation building. He did not point out the issues. He said both have good ground but we need more collaboration. We need to speed it up. Threats and challenges of hybrid and ultra-hybrid wars are increased and for that we are supposed to speed up our cooperation, meaningful cooperation from traditional to integrated security cooperation, vast practical regional cooperation. We should include more regional countries. Signing the documents (MoUs) is not enough, more practical we need to be. Turk-Pak have good position but it is not enough.

    Burhan Kayatürk, Member of Parliament and Chair of the EU Harmonization Committee, Türkiye, underscored the historical bonds and mutual solidarity between the two countries. He called for greater economic cooperation, including achieving the $5 billion bilateral trade target, and highlighted the Makkah Accord’s significance in strengthening regional security and collective security partnerships.

    Muhittin ATAMAN said the Makkah Agreement is like NATO and CENTO. He mentioned three forums as important to face the threats:

    1- Regional Platform, including Egypt, it becomes a political and economic forum as well
    2- Türkiye and Pakistan are members of another such arrangement in which Qatar and Indonesia are also partners. Here they are together for defence industry, joint production and it has great potential for strategic sovereignty.
    3- Türkiye and Azerbaijan Defence Cooperation as Shusha Declaration. Here Pakistan can be invited to join.

    He highlighted their relevance with three points:
    1- Regional – Shared Values / 2- Turk-Pak bilateral cooperation is increased here / 3- Regional Ownership – Regional Solutions for any crisis

    He said these forums are magnets to attract other states to join.Burhan KAYATURK said, “Pakistan, India and China are parties to Kashmir dispute. This dispute cannot be debated at European Parliament. It can be discussed in Asian Parliament only. That is the reason I am promoting the idea of establishment of this Parliament.”

    FETO’s Back Bone Broken- Gulen’s Repatriation from USA Awaited -Ambassador Ihsan Mustafa-by Tazeen Akhtar

    FETO also came under discussion in the forum that was declared a terrorist organization by the incumbent system of President Erdogan in Türkiye. It has great impacts on Pakistan as well because here the project of Pak-Turk Schools/Colleges was launched by the same organization. It was the time of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif when, on the behest of Turkish govt, all schools and colleges were handed over to Maarif and most of the staff was relieved without any proper settlements.

    Mr. KAYATURK mentioned FETO and shared history when he was campaigning for it. He also recalled his meeting with Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed (he was present at the forum) where he was visiting to get support against FETO.

    Turkish govt alleges FETO for conspiring and staging coup d’état attempt in July 2016 that took precious lives of 250 people, mainly supporters of President’s party and others from military. Many independent observers see it in a different way.

    He cherished his memories when he was studying in Pakistan and mentioned Ali Sahin, a close aide to the President, also as a graduate from Pakistan. He said, 6 thousand Pakistanis are studying in Türkiye and we expect the number will be raised.

    ( Here it is pertinent to note, this scribe arranged a forum on Pak-Turk Education Cooperation in collaboration with the Federal Text Book Board (National Book Foundation) in Islamabad last year, taking Turkish Embassy on board. Ambassador, after deeply looking into the arrangements, gave a date and time to attend it but later postponed his participation at the eleventh hour when the guests were invited from concerned departments, without mentioning any reason. He gave no new date afterwards.)

    Türkiye Celebrates 6th Anniversary of Thwarted Coup – Pakistan Reiterates Support Against FETO

    Mr. KAYATURK said, Turk-Pak love each other, our leaders are united but our trade is not satisfactory. We have to upgrade it to $5 Billion. He said Pak-Turk alliance is not enough. We need bigger alliance. Makkah Pact is the start only. We have to gather our resources for security and defence.

    Zarrar Hasham Khan, Secretary, Ministry of Information Technology and Telecommunication, highlighted emerging threats from cyberattacks, disinformation and vulnerabilities in critical information infrastructure. He stressed institutionalising Pakistan–Türkiye cybersecurity cooperation through a bilateral agreement, strengthening digital connectivity and infrastructure resilience, and establishing sustained mechanisms for dialogue and coordination.He suggested Pak Turk Cyber Dialogue led by the Pesidency of Turkiye or Turkish Ministry of IT.

    He said a development between two states on an agreement is likely and we are hopeful it will be signed, on cyber security and threat intelligence sharing.

    ” We are facing big challenges in cyber security as the communication is intercepted and disinformation is spread creating narrative problems. We need protection of criticle infrastructure and our communication should be safe,” Zarrar Hasham noted.

    Prof. Muhittin Ataman, Member of the Security and Foreign Policies Council, Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye, described Pakistan and Türkiye as key pillars of an emerging regional security architecture. He highlighted regional initiatives, including the Makkah Accord, and emphasised regionalism, complementarity, strategic autonomy and regional ownership as essential to addressing regional challenges and promoting lasting peace and stability.

    Earlier, a closed-door STRATCOM Roundtable titled “Türkiye and Pakistan in a Changing Regional Security Architecture: Strategic Cooperation in an Age of Global Crises” brought together senior policymakers, diplomats, security experts and academics from both countries.

    Prof. Ferhat Pirinççi, Deputy Head of Communications, Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye, stressed enhanced cooperation against hybrid threats, cyberattacks, terrorism and disinformation. He discussed emerging security architechture in which he saw the central role of Turkiye and Pakistan.

    Ambassador Moin ul Haque, Director General ISSI, highlighted the longstanding strategic partnership and called for greater cooperation in defence, emerging technologies and counterterrorism.

    End of the Difference: Aliyev and Erdoğan Meet in Karabakh – Banquet in Khankendi Seals the Reconciliation

    Dr. Amina Khan, Director CAMEA, moderated the discussion and highlighted the need for sustained dialogue, closer coordination and stronger Pakistan-Türkiye cooperation amid evolving regional security dynamics.

    The roundtable focused on the evolving regional security architecture, particularly the Makkah Accord, collective security and regional cooperation. Participants emphasised strengthening cybersecurity, strategic communications, economic ties and institutional cooperation to promote regional peace and stability.

    Ambassadors of Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan and Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, DHM of Egypt were also present at the forum. Many other diplomats and media persons also attended the long discussion with keen interest.

    Main take away from the forum was ” Brotherhood is Brotherhood but Business is Business. Turkiye is not satified with present status of Pak Turk trade and defense cooperation. Turkiye does not seem to be ready to contribute defense support against Houthis who are striking civilian infrastructure in Saudi Arabia and challenging safe navigation in Red See.”

    Why Pakistan Keeps Losing in Trade with Turkiye ?

    Every year, Türkiye sells much more to Pakistan than it buys from Pakistan. Türkiye’s exports to Pakistan $918.2 million, Türkiye’s imports from Pakistan $440.1 million, Total trade volume $1,358.3 million / $1.36 billion – Balance – In Türkiye’s favour +$478.1 million.

    PTA is limited: Signed 2022, effective 2023. Türkiye gave concessions on only 261 tariff lines, Pakistan gave on 130. Not a full FTA.

    Non-tariff barriers: Quotas, subsidies, customs delays on Pakistani textiles.

    Similar products: Both produce textiles, agriculture – they compete, not complement.

    No land route: Pakistan-Iran-Türkiye road/rail (RCD / ECO route) still not fully active, so freight is expensive via sea.

    Defence dominates: Political and defence ties are “exemplary”, but commercial ties have not kept pace.

    Target – $5 Billion

    To reach it, they are now talking about:Expanding PTA into a Free Trade Agreement / Trade in Goods Agreement,Special Economic Zone for Turkish businesses in Karachi,Turkish investment in energy, minerals, IT, transport, DISCO privatisation, ship-breaking.

    Pakistan in the World – September 2026