ISLAMABAD: Monitoring Desk – Reporters Without Borders (RSF) has portrayed very gruesome picture of Pakistan regarding freedom of Press with some cases that add weight to the report shared by the international organization working for the safety and rights of journalists worldwide. RSF has urged Pakistan’s new federal and provincial authorities to adopt urgent measures to address the signs of an alarming deterioration in press freedom since they took office three months ago.
Pakistan authorities may have different point of view in this regard. That point of view should be shared to RSF and with Pakistani press as well. Here it is pertinent to recall the latest statement issued by the Council of Pakistan Newspapers Editors CPNE. The Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors (CPNE), only a couple of weeks ago,vehemently rejected the controversial Defamation Bill 2024 passed by the Punjab Assembly, denouncing it as a serious assault on press freedom and branding it a “black law”.
CPNE Islamabad Seeks Amendments in Defamation Bill 2024 Passed in Punjab Assembly
CPNE touched a bill only but here RSF has issued its report that allege more strict measures and actions and the worst is the murder of journalists. RSF raises the question, “What with murders of journalists, an enforced disappearance, arbitrary detention, censorship and social media blocking, everything points to a very disturbing decline in press freedom in the first three months since the new federal and provincial governments took over at the start of March following elections in February.”
Editor Tazeen Akhtar commented on RSF report as , “One very important point can be noted here that Pakistani authorities especially the top slots of civil and armed forces are being hit and humiliated at social media that is still highly irresponsible media in Pakistan. More strict laws and rules are mainly meant for this media and not for mainstream media / press as both are doing their work with responsibility , not hitting below the belt in the name of press freedom or freedom of expression.”
Célia Mercier, Head of RSF’s South Asia desk says;
“The many press freedom violations reveal a climate of violence and a determination to censor that has little in common with the undertakings given by the political parties in their elections campaign manifestos, and the message of support for journalists by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. The strategy of suppressing critical voices is becoming ever more visible, amid claims that the results of the election were tainted by fraud and continuing army interference in politics.”
“Pakistan remains one of the world’s most dangerous countries for media personnel, and the level of impunity for murders of journalists is appalling. RSF reiterates its call to Pakistan’s new leaders at the national and provincial level to adopt urgent measures to restore press freedom, Célia Mercier adds.
-
Murders of journalists
Kamran Dawar, a freelance journalist in the northwestern district of North Waziristan who ran a YouTube channel and a Facebook TV news channel called Waziristan TV, was murdered on 21 May, just weeks after telling colleagues he feared for his safety.
Nasrullah Gadani, a reporter for the Awami Awaz newspaper in the southern province of Sindh who criticised the feudal system in his region, was riddled with bullets by gunmen on a motorcycle the same day, and died of his injuries three days later.
-
Abduction by intelligence agents
Ali Ahmed Farhad Shah, a freelance journalist and poet who is very critical of the army and who comes from Azad Kashmir, the Pakistani part of the northeastern Jammu and Kashmir region, was abducted from his home in the capital, Islamabad, on 15 May. After his wife filed a legal petition, the Azad Kashmir police finally revealed that they were holding Shah because he had shared “provocative material” on Facebook during protests in the region – in which he did not participate because he was in Islamabad. An anti-terrorism court in Muzaffarabad, Azad Kashmir’s capital, rejected a request for his release on bail on 4 June.
(Here RSF has not observed the follow up that he is free now and no evidence of his abduction by any intelligence agency has been pleaded or proved in the concerned court. Moreover he is a poet and not a journalist.)
-
Arbitrary detentions, press clubs harassed
Sher Afgan, a journalist with the Bol News TV channel who is the president of the press club in Dera Ghazi Khan, a city in Punjab province, and Ghulam Mustafa, a reporter for the Daily Ausaf newspaper and president of the Anjuman-e-Sahafyan (Union of Journalists), were detained on 7 May for objecting to a police raid on the press club during a press conference by supporters of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), the party of imprisoned former Prime Minister Imran Khan.
On 18 May, police surrounded the press club in Quetta, the capital of the southwestern province of Balochistan, to prevent a Baloch group from holding a press conference about enforced disappearances.
-
Trumped-up charges against journalists forced to flee abroad
An absurd case against two journalists who have had to flee to the United States was revived by an anti-terrorism court in Islamabad at the end of May. The two journalists – YouTuber Wajahat Saeed Khan and Shaheen Sehbai, the former editor of The News International newspaper – have been subjected to trumped-up charges of conspiring to “weaken the army” and “increase terrorism” since June 2023.
-
New censorship measures
On 3 May, the federal government announced the creation of a National Cyber Crimes Investigation Agency (NCCIA) to monitor online content.
The controversial Punjab Defamation Act of 2024 was passed by the Punjab provincial government on 20 May. Under this new law, proof of harm is not needed to bring defamation actions, impose fines on media and journalists, and block their accounts.
On 21 May, the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) banned TV news channels from broadcasting information about “ongoing court cases” until a final verdict is announced. Nonetheless, in response to petitions by a journalists’ organisation, the Islamabad High Court and High Court of Sindh said in rulings issued in early June that journalists were free to cover court cases.
-
X blocked since February
Access to the social media platform X (the former Twitter) has been intermittently blocked on “national security” grounds since the general elections in early February. The aim has been to stifle any protests since the elections, which were marked by allegations of fraud.
Situation Worse in Pakistan for Press Freedom – CPNE Releases “Pakistan Media Freedom Report – 2021”
